South Korea’s Supreme Court has overturned the 15-year prison sentence imposed on former prime minister Han Duck-soo over his role in former president Yoon Suk Yeol’s failed martial law attempt, sending the case back to the Seoul High Court for reconsideration.
The ruling, delivered on Thursday, 19 November, partially reversed the lower court’s findings on Han’s involvement in the events of December 2024. The Supreme Court concluded that prosecutors had not sufficiently established that Han intended to support Yoon’s unlawful declaration by proposing a Cabinet meeting before martial law was imposed.
However, the decision did not clear Han of all responsibility. The justices left several findings concerning his actions after the declaration undisturbed, including attempts to obtain Cabinet members’ signatures on related documents and discussions about restricting utilities to media organisations critical of the government.
The 9–3 decision has become one of the most significant judicial developments in South Korea’s continuing political reckoning with the martial law crisis. Han remains in custody while the Seoul High Court reviews the case, following a two-month extension of his detention ordered by the Supreme Court.
Supreme Court questions evidence of prior involvement
The central issue before the Supreme Court was whether Han had deliberately helped Yoon prepare and legitimise the declaration of emergency martial law on 3 December 2024.
The appellate court had found that Han played a key role in the insurrection, including by proposing that Yoon convene a Cabinet meeting before announcing martial law. Prosecutors argued that this meeting was intended to create the appearance that the declaration had undergone the required constitutional consultation.
The Supreme Court disagreed with that assessment.
A majority of the justices concluded that the evidence did not adequately establish Han’s intention to facilitate Yoon’s plan or prove that he knew about the president’s intentions beforehand. The judges considered the circumstances surrounding the meeting and the urgency of the events before the declaration.
The ruling therefore overturned the lower court’s finding that Han’s role in arranging the pre-declaration Cabinet meeting demonstrated participation in the attempted power grab.
However, the justices reached a different conclusion about several actions that followed the announcement.
The court did not disturb findings that Han attempted to obtain signatures from Cabinet members on a martial-law-related document and discussed the implementation of orders concerning the restriction of electricity and water supplies to certain media organisations.
Those findings remain important to the case and explain why the Supreme Court did not simply acquit Han or order his immediate release.
Han’s prison sentence and the next stage of proceedings
Han was initially sentenced to 23 years in prison by a district court in January 2026 after being convicted of multiple offences connected to Yoon’s martial law declaration.
The Seoul High Court reduced that sentence to 15 years in May after overturning some of the original findings, including aspects of the accusations concerning Han’s failure to stop the declaration.
Han appealed against the remaining convictions, arguing that his actions did not amount to participation in an insurrection. He denied most of the allegations, although he admitted a separate perjury charge.
The Supreme Court’s ruling means that the 15-year sentence cannot stand in its existing form. The case has been returned to the Seoul High Court, which must reconsider the findings in light of the Supreme Court’s legal conclusions.
This is not a final acquittal. The lower court will have to reassess the case, including the legal significance of the conduct that the Supreme Court did not overturn.
The Supreme Court also extended Han’s detention by two months, meaning he will remain in custody while the proceedings continue. The decision came just one day before his existing detention period was due to expire.
Court confirms Yoon’s martial law declaration was unconstitutional
Although the Supreme Court partially overturned the findings against Han, it made an important constitutional determination concerning the original martial law declaration.
Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae stated that the emergency martial law imposed on 3 December 2024 was incompatible with South Korea’s constitutional order and violated citizens’ basic rights.
The finding is significant because it reinforces the legal conclusion that the declaration itself was unlawful. It also distinguishes the question of whether Yoon’s actions were unconstitutional from the separate question of how much responsibility individual government officials bear for their conduct.
The legal proceedings against Han have focused on whether his actions amounted to participation in the insurrection associated with the declaration.
The Supreme Court’s decision does not erase the constitutional significance of the original events. Instead, it narrows the grounds on which Han’s personal criminal responsibility can be established.
The court’s reasoning is likely to be closely examined in other proceedings connected to the December 2024 crisis, particularly cases involving officials accused of facilitating or executing the former president’s orders.
Recalling the December 2024 martial law crisis
Yoon Suk Yeol announced emergency martial law late on 3 December 2024, arguing that extraordinary measures were necessary to confront what he described as anti-state forces and political obstruction.
The announcement triggered an immediate political and constitutional crisis.
Military and police personnel were deployed around the National Assembly in Seoul as lawmakers moved to challenge the decree. Despite the security restrictions, legislators entered the parliamentary chamber and voted to demand the lifting of martial law.
The National Assembly’s vote forced the government to reverse the declaration, which lasted approximately six hours.
The episode shocked South Korea, a country whose modern democratic institutions developed after decades of authoritarian rule and military-backed governments.
Yoon was impeached by lawmakers on 14 December 2024. South Korea’s Constitutional Court subsequently upheld his impeachment and removed him from office in April 2025.
The former president later faced criminal proceedings over the declaration. A district court sentenced him to life imprisonment in February 2026 after convicting him of leading an insurrection. He has appealed against that ruling, with the appellate decision scheduled for January 2027.
Han’s case is part of the broader judicial process examining the roles played by senior officials during the crisis.
Political reaction intensifies after the ruling
The Supreme Court’s decision immediately generated political controversy.
South Korea’s governing Democratic Party criticised the ruling, with some members accusing Chief Justice Cho of judicial misconduct and raising the possibility of seeking his impeachment.
Party figures argued that the decision risked weakening accountability for senior officials involved in the martial law episode.
The criticism reflects the continued political sensitivity surrounding Yoon’s declaration and the question of how responsibility should be assigned among members of his former administration.
The special prosecution team handling Han’s case said it respected the Supreme Court’s decision. However, the ruling is likely to remain a major subject of debate as the lower court resumes consideration of the case.
The opposition’s reaction also demonstrates that the dispute is no longer confined to the courtroom. The martial law crisis continues to influence relations between political parties, the judiciary and the institutions responsible for safeguarding South Korea’s constitutional system.
A separate ruling involving Yoon’s wife
The Supreme Court also delivered a separate ruling on Thursday concerning former first lady Kim Keon Hee, upholding her four-year prison sentence.
Kim was convicted in connection with stock price manipulation and accepting bribes, including luxury gifts linked to individuals seeking influence.
The ruling against Kim is legally separate from Han’s case, but it forms part of the wider series of proceedings involving people close to the former presidential administration.
Both decisions underline the continuing legal consequences of the political crisis that followed Yoon’s martial law declaration.
What the decision means for South Korea’s institutions
The Supreme Court’s ruling presents a complicated outcome for South Korea’s efforts to establish accountability for the 2024 crisis.
On one hand, the court confirmed that the martial law declaration was unconstitutional and unlawful. It also left significant findings concerning Han’s post-declaration conduct undisturbed.
On the other hand, it rejected the argument that the evidence sufficiently proved Han’s intention to help legitimise the declaration through the pre-declaration Cabinet meeting.
The decision therefore reinforces an important principle of criminal justice: senior officials cannot be convicted solely on the basis of their positions or proximity to unlawful political decisions. Prosecutors must establish the required criminal intent and demonstrate the individual’s specific role.
The forthcoming proceedings at the Seoul High Court will determine how those legal standards affect Han’s final criminal liability and sentence.
For South Korea, the case remains part of a wider test of democratic resilience following an extraordinary confrontation between the presidency and the legislature.
The Supreme Court has drawn a distinction between the illegality of Yoon’s martial law declaration and the evidence required to establish Han’s individual responsibility. Whether that distinction ultimately results in a reduced sentence or a different legal outcome will now depend on the lower court’s reconsideration.
